Posted

in

,

by

Tags:


We’re looking at Oscar contenders as they release and trying to determine which films have potential and which have wasted it. Let’s look back at the month of October and see what films succeeded and faltered. Then we’ll look forward to December and see what has some potential.

Wesley Lovell’s Thoughts

October Retrospective
A surprisingly large number of major Oscar contenders went down in the month of October with major filmmakers and one mini-major one all releasing films that were poorly received by critics, likely ending their chances at Oscar glory. There were a few minor contenders that either confirmed they weren’t in the race, and a couple of early festival titles that performed well. Then there are the expected contenders that did well enough or beyond expectations.

I’ll kick things off with the three major contenders that flopped. Digger takes the lead here. Alejandro G. Iñárritu’s satire about consumerism, the oil industry, and feckless, warmongering politicos, was savaged by critics and landed the filmmaker his worst reviews in years. While this won’t necessarily prevent nominations for Tom Cruise in lead, John Goodman in support, and the film’s cinematography or production design, they are no longer the guarantees they once were while the film itself will be lucky to land those three specific citations.

One that might fare a little better but not by much is Aaron Sorkin’s fourth directorial effort The Social Reckoning. Although he is considered one of the greatest working screenwriters, his directorial skills are uneven. He could still pick up an Adapted Screenplay nomination for this film but the film looks to be fading quickly into obscurity and I wouldn’t be surprised to see it completely forgotten by the end of the year.

Klara and the Sun is from mini-major director Taika Waititi whose star rose quickly and seems to be fading just as fast. Based on the acclaimed Kazuo Ishiguro novel, the film had a lot of promise going into awards season but tanked when critics finally saw it. The absence from the festival circuit foreshadowed that. While it could still show up in some below-the-line craft categories, it’s safe to say that the film will be out of the running for much else.

We’ll start out our section of films that I highlighted back in September that ended up about where I expected. Verity tops that list as a potential vehicle for an Anne Hathaway nomination but ended up being about as underwhelming in terms of critic response and box office as every other psychosexual horror-thriller of recent vintage. It probably never should have been given a berth in the Oscar competition and has been left at the station already.

Clayface wasn’t going to be a box office behemoth because horror and comic books don’t sell well to audiences. Superhero enthusiasts have grown increasingly disappointed with the big screen offerings and few such titles have done well in the last couple of years (Spider-Man notwithstanding). Meanwhile, horror fans are looking for something a little less animated and a little more traditional. Clayface still ended up with decent reviews and has become the most successful body horror film of all time but that won’t bolster its chances with Oscar. It remains a contender in Best Makeup & Hairstyling (if enough prosthetics were used) and/or Best Visual Effects (if there weren’t any).

Starting out on the festival circuit, A Talent for Murder held minimal promise for star Helen Mirren as a Best Actress contender. The film was well regarded for the most part but was a box office dud. With the stiff competition in the lead categories at the Oscars, it seems unlikely Mirren will parlay this into another late-career nomination but stranger things have happened.

Wicker is the one film I’m not quite sure about how Oscar voters will take it. Critics generally loved it. Audiences did too. It’s a romantasy film about a woman having wicker man made for her sexual and emotional pleasure. Had this starred anyone other than Oscar winner Olivia Colman and Oscar contender Alexander Skarsgärd, it likely would have been forgotten. Both leads, the film’s production design, costume design, and makeup could all be contenders but it remains on the periphery of the competition at present.

The weakest of the indie Oscar contenders that released in October was Sense and Sensibility. The latest rendition of the classic Jane Austen novel has a relatively small profile because of its director and cast. Meanwhile, the critics were generally positive but not ecstatic. While the film is still a slight contender for most categories, the only places I can see it doing well are Best Production Design and Best Costume Design.

It’s been seven years since Laika Animation released its last Best Animated Feature contender. It’s been an additional three years since Travis Knight made a film for them. Wildwood is the result. With a staggering 98% fresh rating at Rotten Tomatoes, an impressive 87 Metacritic score, and a surprisingly healthy box office take with minimal drops each weekend, the film is poised to be a major contender for the Best Animated Feature Oscar with nominations for Original Score, Production Design, Costume Design, Sound, and Visual Effects also possible and the latter likely. While it was believed that Knight’s previous Kubo and the Two Strings would finally bring the studio its first Oscar, all signs right now suggest this might finally do it. Unless I’m forgetting something, it’s the best reviewed animated feature of the year. It could even get a Best Picture nomination, though that’s a bit on the outside of chances. Now we just have to see if it sweeps the precursors.

Director Cristian Mungiu is no stranger to the Oscars but he’s but he’s never been nominated in the major categories. Fjord will likely change that. With excellent reviews and the Palme d’Or from Cannes, this could well be his year. With numerous potential nominations, including Best Picture, Directing, Actor (Sebastian Stan), Actress (Renate Reinsve), and several other categories, this film will be a hot player with critics. We’ll just see how it’s received in terms of nominations or prizes.

La Bola Negra came out of Toronto (International Film Festival) a film to beat. Although the initial reviews from Toronto weren’t exactly revolutionary, it’s since begun to build towards a potential Best Picture win. Something about the film isn’t exactly off-putting but perhaps oversold. This is the kind of film that builds a post-festival conversation without having the merit to back it up and while I expect it will get several nominations, I suspect it will ultimately get far fewer than anyone predicted and will ultimately go home empty-handed.

It’s hard to say where Lee Chang-dong’s Possible Love will place in the Oscar contest. Although it’s well reviewed, the film seems like one of those tasty foreign entries that are overwhelmed by bigger and smaller films with better marketing teams. It’s rare for a well regarded festival morsel to make inroads with Oscar voters when they are awash with contenders. It could still perform decently but I wouldn’t count on it doing too well.

And that’s everything from October.

December Forecast
With December the final month for Oscar consideration, a lot of the film’s we haven’t seen much from yet (or anything at all in some cases) will finally reach the surface and we’ll see if early forecasts remain true or a fantasy.

The two titles that haven’t been seen by anyone yet are Avengers: Doomsday, Werwulf, and Dune: Par Three. Both titles have a very specific track to the Oscars that they could take. Avengers: Doomsday is a Best Visual Effects contender and maybe one for Best Sound as well. It doesn’t matter how good it is, it won’t make the Best Picture race.

Dune: Part Three on the other hand is the long-awaited finale to Denis Villeneuve’s Paul Atreides trilogy. This one, the only film based on a single book, will see the end of the character played by Timothée Chalamet. While the trilogy can be understood without the books as a foundation, it will be incredibly difficult. Fans are there for it and critics could be too. If the critics don’t like the final film, it might still score several Oscar nominations but it won’t receive the same outpouring of support that Peter Jackson’s Lord of the Rings trilogy did. With Villeneuve never having gotten a Best Directing nomination for the series, it clearly doesn’t have the same appreciation. That said, a huge performance at the box office and strong reviews might bolster its chances.

Finally, is the biggest question mark of the three. Werwulf is the latest Robert Eggers reinvention of a familiar horror tale. This latest folk horror tale looks like most of his past films, all successful and well regarded by critics but virtually ignored by the Oscars. Considering the competition, I just can’t see it cracking the upper categories and fighting for nominations in the crafts. Truly rapturous reviews could change that calculus but so far it’s Obsession that’s turning out to be this year’s horror wunderkind.

There are four films that have barely been seen and there’s not enough information to declare them viable or dead. Clarissa recently showed up on the nominations list of the Gotham Awards. It’s the first time the film has made an appearance outside of early prognosticators’ lists and could be a sign of things to come. That said, an indie film releasing this late in the year is going to face serious headwinds. It will take amazingly good reviews to bolster its chances into the final stretch, though an acting nomination or two could still sneak in.

Ink is the latest film from an Oscar-winning director (Danny Boyle) to fail to build interest late in the year. While it’s been seen in some places, actual buzz around it never materialized and it seems likely the film will not make much of an impact in the Oscar race without significantly better and more potent reviews.

Meanwhile, Rose has been seen on the festival circuit but not since. That puts it in minds early but Sandra Hüller building buzz for another film, the chances of a dual nomination after the Academy changed its rules to allow such seem slim at this point. It could benefit from a lot of nominations from critics and strong on-release reviews, but we’ll have to see.

Lastly, is a figure we once thought unbeatable. Mike Leigh has scored so many writing and directing nominations in his career, it was thought he could never fail. And then he did. Tender Loving Care gives him a chance to course correct and although it has been seen, it hasn’t been viewed widely making it a late contender that could do incredibly well with enough support. Of course, that’s what we thought about Hard Truths and the Academy ignored. We’ll have to see how things play out.

Lastly is a batch of films with good to great reviews that have nevertheless failed to build the kind of buzz that makes them unstoppable. Starting with the most likely Oscar contender of the bunch: The Debut. Writer/director Jesse Eisenberg’s new film takes place in a small town theatre where a disillusioned house wife decides to take a stab at acting in a community production. The comedy stars Julianne Moore who’s got plenty of buzz and is very likely assured a nomination and Paul Giamatti who broke his Oscar curse but who might struggle against a stacked category. The film is sure to be nominated for its writing but Best Picture is still a question mark while Best Directing is unlikely. Best Film Editing is also possible but at this point, two-to-three nominations are assured.

Next up is Ray Gunn, director Brad Bird’s first film outside the Disney/Pixar pipeline has been seen by enough critics to sound like a strong contender for a Best Animated Feature nomination. While it could also be in the hunt for a win, its lack of potential in categories outside of its music might hinder its chances. We’ll see where the reviews and critic prizes land.

Up next is Luca Guadagnino’s look at the rise of Sam Altman. Artificial is reminiscent of The Social Network in its view of tech CEOs who’ve risen to power on innovation and whose sociopathic tendencies make them dislikable characters. The early reviews are solid, at least better than The Social Reckoning, but may not be sufficient to score the film or any of its principles nominations. A writing nomination is possible as are nominations for stars Andrew Garfield, Yura Borisov, and Monica Barbaro, but it remains to be seen if it can outclass the rest of this year’s contenders.

Lastly is Behemoth!, Tony Gilroy’s tribute to cinematic music stars Pedro Pascal and Olivia Wilde. Pascal is probably the lone contender for this film and even he doesn’t seem like a guarantee. The film has gotten decent but not ecstatic reviews and doesn’t seem to be moving the needle nearly as much as some of its compatriots. That said, great on-release reviews and nominations from critics could bolster its chances.

And that’s it for this month. A plethora of options and no clear paths for many of them. Next month, we’ll finish up the November retrospective and the forecasts will diminish into 2027 territory. Before then, here are the responses of Cinema Sight’s other contributors.

Pete Patrick’s Thoughts

October Retrospective
Another month has come and gone offering mostly disappointing releases either in terms of box-office, Oscar prospects, or both, with two exceptions.

The first exception is the animated feature, Wildwood, which will probably sweep year-end animation awards and go on to be the Oscar front-runner for Best Animated Feature. A nod for Best Picture as well would not be surprising.

The second exception is the Elizabeth Holmes documentary; You Can See Everything which is not only going to dominate documentary awards but is apt to feature in Best Picture discussions from critics’ awards to the Oscars where it is being predicted to not only be nominated but finish in the top three alongside La Bola Negra and The Odyssey.

Chief among the many disappointments was the Tom Cruise dramedy, Digger, which had been touted sight unseen as one of the year’s major Oscar contenders before the critics got hold of it and tore it to shreds.

Suffering from mixed reviews, Aaron Sorkin’s The Social Reckoning came and went without much fanfare, a far cry from the success of 2010’s The Social Network.

Despite strong reviews from critics, the 2026 version of Jane Austen’s Sense and Sensibility hasn’t fared well at the box office and aside from a Gotham Awards nomination for Esmée Creed-Miles hasn’t fared well in the still very early end-of-year film awards. An Oscar nod for Best Costume Design may be the only one it gets.

December Forecast
There is something for everyone this Christmas season including the blockbusters, Avengers: Doomsday and Dune: Part Three. The latter is expected to be a Best Picture contender along with several technical nods.

Awards contender La Bola Negra, which has only been available in very limited engagements until now, makes its Netflix debut on December 1 where the masses can judge its awards worthiness along with those who have already seen it.

Luca Guadagnino’s Artificial about the confusing firing and rehiring cycle of Sam Altman at OpenAI has been receiving major awards buzz for Yura Borisov as Russian scientist Ilya Sutskever and Andrew Garfield as Altman.

Mike Leigh’s latest domestic drama and possibly his last film, Tender Loving Care is one of three major British films releasing in December.

Danny Boyle’s Ink starring Guy Pearce as newspaper mogul Rupert Murdoch and Jack O’Connell as his muckraking editor Larry Lamb could see awards glory for the two actors, probably more so in the U.K. than on this side of the Atlantic, but you never know.

Simon Stone’s Elsinore has been receiving major awards talk for Andrew Scott for his performance as actor Ian Charleson giving his all to a London National Theatre portrayal of Hamlet while dying of AIDS in 1990.

The most highly anticipated comedy of the year, Jesse Eisenberg’s The Debut starring Julianne Moore and Paul Giamatti, both in highly anticipated performances, will more than likely be the go-to hit of the season for those looking for something lighter than the heavy drama being offered by the rest of the month’s major releases.

Thomas La Tourrette’s Thoughts

October Retrospective
We have finally gotten into the fall prestige releases, so there are several films that could rack up Oscar nominations. However, most of the releases were not as good as expected, so it does not look like much will come out of them.

I thought Digger would be a major player. Everyone had it listed in multiple categories, but it landed with a thud. It will probably get a nom for Makeup & Hairstyling, but that might be it. Tom Cruise could pick up a nomination, but if someone from a better movie comes along, I think he will be replaced.

I am not sure what to make of The Social Reckoning, a companion piece though not a sequel to the excellent The Social Network. It opened to rather poor reviews, so I doubt it will pick up any nominations.

Fjord has gotten great reviews, and I thought it would get nominations for picture, director, actor, actress, and original screenplay. It is one of the few films opening in the month where we have reviews to go by. It will be nominated for International film, but I think it will be just off the list in the other categories.

Sense and Sensibility looks likely to only pick up a nomination for costume design.

Wicker will probably get a nomination for Makeup and Hairstyling.

Fatherland also is getting strong reviews, and I had expected it to do well with the Academy. Now it seems to be falling off the radar and will probably only manage a nom for cinematography and perhaps International Film.

John Turturro is getting perhaps the best reviews of his career for The Only Living Pickpocket in New York, but his unshowy performance may not be enough in a very crowded field. He might sneak in for the final spot, but he and Tom Cruise right now are battling for that spot.

Clayface might get a nom for Makeup and Hairstyling, but it is more likely to just finish out of the top five.

The very long Musk could pull off a nomination for documentary feature, but the sheer length may keep viewers and Academy voters away.

Much more likely to pull off a nomination is You Can See Everything, which at this point is the frontrunner for Documentary feature. Of course, the Academy often seems to not nominate the frontrunner, so time will tell.

December Forecast
I would have expected December to have more films that would pull off nominations across the board, but Dune: Part Three is the only new release that is likely to have more than two niminations.

Behemoth! might pick up a nomination for score, but that looks to be its only possibility.

Ava Duvernay’s documentary 14th might pull off a nomination.

Ray Gunn should definitely pick up a nomination for animated feature.

Tender Loving Care might pull off a nomination for original screenplay and has an outside chance of a supporting actress nom too.

The Debut will put Julianne Moore into the mix for best actress where she is already the frontrunner. It will probably get a nom for original song too and possibly for picture as well.

Ink and Clarissa had early buzz but neither seem likely to score nominations at this point. The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth probably falls into the same boat.

Rose looks more likely to be the film where Sandra Hüller picks up a nomination for best actress rather than Fatherland.

Dune: Part Three should clean up in the tech categories. It will probably get nominated for best picture, but director and adapted screenplay nominations are less likely. It will be interesting to see how it does as the final Lord of the Rings movie swept the Oscars but the sequel to Wicked got nothing. I doubt it will do either of those, but I could see it not getting as many noms as expected.

Avengers: Doomsday has a very outside chance for a visual effects nom, but that feels unlikely.

Werwulf might be up for production design, costume design, and more assuredly for Makeup and Hairstyling.

Artificial is on the cusp for picture and original screenplay nominations, but it looks like Andrew Garfield will have to wait awhile for another nomination.

Oscar Hopefuls Header

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

Verified by MonsterInsights