Posted

in

by

Tags:


Warner Archive has released a Blu-ray upgrade of 1944’s Mr. Skeffington, which like all Archive’s upgrades looks and sounds better than it ever has. The question, though, is why this film when two of Davis’s best, 1943’s Watch on the Rhine and 1945’s The Corn Is Green, although two for she was nominated for an Oscar, are still missing on Blu-ray.

Directed by Vincent Sherman, Mr. Skeffington in my estimation features the least deserving of all Bette Davis’s Oscar-nominated performances.

No one can complain about the legendary actresses’ five consecutive nominations from 1938-1942 which included Jezebel for which she won her second Best Actress Oscar Dark Victory, The Letter, The Little Foxes and Now, Voyager, but in 1944 there were five much better lead actress performances in dramatic films, some of which, like Davis’s, were directed at women. They were those of Tallulah Bankhead, who won the New York Film Critics’ award for Lifeboat, Ingrid Bergman who won the Golden Globe for Gaslight, Claudette Colbert for Since You Went Away, Irene Dunne for The White Cliffs of Dover and Barbara Stanwyck for Double Indemnity.

Oscar nominated three of the year’s best lead actress performances, those of Bergman, Colbert and Stanwyck with Bergman winning. Bankhead and Dunne were overlooked in favor of Davis and Greer Garson in Mrs, Parkington.

Garson’s nomination was for another women’s picture, in which she like Davis, ages from a young woman to an even older one than Davis. Davis ends up at about 50 whereas Garson ended up in her 80s. Ironically, Gladys Cooper who played Davis’s mother in Now, Voyager and Dunne’s mother-in-law in The White Cliffs of Dover played Garson’s daughter in Mrs. Parkington the year before she played her prospective mother-in-law in The Valley of Decision. She would end her Hollywood career playing Garson’s aunt in 1967’s The Happiest Millionaire.

Garson, whose career peaked with the double whammy of 1942’s Mrs. Miniver and Random Harvest, would tie Davis’s record five consecutive nominations the following year with The Valley of Decision having been previously nominated for Blossoms in the Dust, Mrs. Miniver for which she won, and Madame Curie. Her performance in Mrs. Parkington was like Davis’s performance in Mr. Skeffington, the least memorable of her multiple nominations.

Garson’s nomination came at the expense of Dunne’s superior work as the nurse who loses her husband to World War I and her son to World War II in the box-office behemoth, The White Cliffs of Dover. Davis’s came at the expense of Tallulah Bankhead as the bitchy newspaper photojournalist in Alfred Hitchcock’s one-set World War II suspenser, Lifeboat which is ironic considering that Davis’s acclaimed performance in The Little Foxes was to many a carbon copy of Bankhead’s performance in the Broadway version.

Neither Mrs. Parkington nor Mr. Skeffington are bad movies, they’ve just not very good ones.

In Mr. Skeffington, Davis plays against type as beautiful but vain, selfish woman who marries a man she doesn’t love to help her equally selfish younger brother avoid arrest for embezzling the man she marries and spends the next 30 years being mean to. Claude Rains, nominated for Best Supporting Actor, plays the titled Mr. Skeffington to Davis’s Mrs. Skeffington with dignity and restraint that borders on the ridiculous considering his circumstances. Walter Abel co-stars as Davis’s cousin and fixer. Dorothy Peterson plays Davis’s faithful maid. Marjorie Riordan plays Davi’s grown daughter who spent most of her life growing up with her father who Davis divorced so she could carry on with a succession of silly admirers. The rest of the huge cast is mostly wasted.

Extras include Sherman’s 2005 commentary which he did for the film’s initial DVD release less than a year before his death at 99.

Universal has released a Blu-ray upgrade of 1943’s The Amazing Mrs. Holliday, the film that was supposed to be Deanna Durbin’s breakthrough as a dramatic actress rather than the light comedienne and singer she had been throughout her childhood and young adulthood. It was also supposed to be director Jean Renoir’s American film debut.

Durbin and Judy Garland had both made their debuts in MGM’s 1936 short, Every Sunday but MGM given the option of only putting one under contract chose Garland. Durbin was then signed by Durbin where her lighthearted films were said to save the studio from bankruptcy. Consequently, her first two films for Universal, 1936’s Three Smart Girls and 1937’s One Hundred Men and a Girl were both Oscar nominated for Best Picture.

Durbin was even better in 1938’s Mad About Music and That Certain Age and as a result received an honorary Oscar for 1938 along with Mickey Rooney whose 1938 output included Boys Town and Love Finds Andy Hardy. Garland had to wait another year for hers, the year of The Wizard of Oz and Babes in Arms.

Durbin continued to thrill audiences with 1939’s First Love and 1941’s It Started with Eve.amoing others.

Durbin had wanted to film The Amazing Mrs. Holliday without having to sing but was given five songs to sing, which she does beautifully as usual. Renoir quit the film the day before filming began due to lack of a finished script but came back uncredited to direct, according to Durbin, two-thirds of the film with the credit going to scriptwriter Bruce Manning.

Durbin plays the schoolteacher daughter of a missionary who is tasked with overseeing the evacuation of nine orphans from war-torn China. None of the orphans, who were originally from countries all over the world, have birth certificates. The death of one of them in a bomb attack makes their evacuation even more urgent. They find shelter in a boat headed for San Franscisco without the knowledge of the captain played by Harry Davenport. Once he finds out, he vows to adopt the children to make them legal refugees. However, he dies before he can carry out the adoption and Durbin is left at the mercy of his family to provide help. Enter Edmond O’Brien as Davenport’s grandson and Durbin’s love interest.

Barry Fitzgerald co-stars as Davenport’s deckhand and Durbin’s protector.

The Universal release does not have any extras but does have English subtitles for the deaf and hard of hearing.

Happy viewing.

Oscar Hopefuls Header

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

Verified by MonsterInsights